In my search for the best OEM replacement filter I evaluated the Baldwin 1422, they are VERY high quality filters. All you got to do is hold a Baldwin and you know its a serious piece of kit, same solid feel and build quality as in the Toyo-Roki OEMs. I'd say its at least as good as the OEM short but it does have a denser filter media, but most non Japanese filters do. I'd say its definitely better than anything you can get in an auto parts store but unless its cheaper the OEM short is your best bet.