I would imagine pretty much everyone will prefer whatever they have.
My explanation for liking popups is because when I fell in love with the shape of the NSX, that was the one I dreamed about. So when you get older, do less stupid stuff, and get nostalgic about those old cars you never had, then those are the ones you buy. I still think the 1993 Mustang Cobra is cool, and it's because I remember seeing one almost every morning roll into the parking lot when I was in school. So if I was looking for a cobra, then even though the newer ones have huge improvements, I'd lean towards that old 93. Hence the popups for me.