Jason,
I went to a local auto paint store and found a product from a company called mar-hyde, TAL-STRIP II, Aircraft Coating Remover. It strips finishes and primers from aluminum and other metals. It comes in a spray can and all you do is spray it on, wait 10-15 minutes and then just hose it off with a garden hose. (The paint will simply blister up like something from a science fiction movie.)
What you're left with is a raw piece of aluminum that is sort of a splotchy silver-tannish color. I then started sanding the strut bar with 500 grit wet/dry sandpaper by wrapping the paper around the bar and moving up and down........well, I won't get into what the motion is REALLY like.
I then worked with 1000 grit and then finished with 2000 grit to remove all the fine scratches.
The strut bar does not come to life until you apply the Mothers Mag and Aluminum Polish (or any sort of aluminum and mag polish in paste form) with a rag in the same motion. The rag will turn black from all the oxidization that comes off from the polish and then simply use a clean rag to wipe it down after that. NOTE: You do not need to use a clearcoat protectant on the strut bar. Just an occasional wipe down with the polish on a rag and it will look like a million bucks.
If you desire the look of brushed aluminum then I would suggest lightly sanding the strut bar with 1000 grit or lower after the polishing procedure. For an even greater "brushed" look you can use a courser grit wet/dry sandpaper.
I found some chrome 12mm bolt head covers to conceal the two bolts on each side that hold the strut bar to the chassis to dress it up even further.
Total Cost: $10. ($5 for polish and $5 for bolt head covers.)
Time: 1-2 hours; depending on finish desired. Brushed or polished.
Have Fun.
[This message has been edited by Chris W (edited 07 April 2001).]