• Protip: Profile posts are public! Use Conversations to message other members privately. Everyone can see the content of a profile post.

Do you think we're in the next Great Depression? Y/N

Are we in (or about to enter) the next Great Depression?

  • No

    Votes: 61 53.0%
  • Yes

    Votes: 54 47.0%

  • Total voters
    115
  • Poll closed .
showimage.asp


Consumer confidence dropped again today.

Thursday should be REALLY interesting with the employment numbers coming in. If they miss by any large margin the Dow will be at 5K within a few months.
 
The numbers are rigged. It's a joke. They don't count, they calculate unemployment. There are many factors such as 50k "seasonal" construction jobs simply "included" in the employment figures by default. Unemployment by the definition of the actual term is already a mininum of 8.5% nationwide.

It's no different than when the government "adjusted" how they "calculated" inflation at the realization of the inflection point with SS benfits. In order to get it under control they lowered inflation through "adjusting" the calculation. Keeping payments fixed, lowering benefits. It's rigged.
 
Its a very good point sahtt - Just look at our GDP numbers... we now know we were actually in a recession way back in '07 but the gov't was manipulating the numbers to another conclusion for the better part of a year.
 
The next Simpsons episode:

Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion


(I told you so)
 
The next Simpsons episode:

Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion
Our economy hasn't been fueled by credit expansion


(I told you so)



lol. It's true. How long can America pay it's mortgage payment with it's credit card? That's the question.
 
The Terminator is now giving out IOUs instead of U.S. Dollar tax refunds for people that overpaid in 2008. :tongue: Anyone seen Dumb and Dumber?

Sorry for our Cali contingency... other states will follow unless the Feds plug the hole (quite likely).
 
other states will follow unless the Feds plug the hole (quite likely).

How are they going to plug the hole? Simply borrow more money from China and give it to Cali? I guess that's all they can do right?

Man, we're lucky China is being so cool about this. Without them we would without a doubt be in a great depression right now.
 
How are they going to plug the hole? Simply borrow more money from China and give it to Cali? I guess that's all they can do right?

Man, we're lucky China is being so cool about this. Without them we would without a doubt be in a great depression right now.

You are very right. We are lucky china has been so good about it so far. But I wouldn't expect them to continue eating our shit sandwich forever. I saw "The Ascent of Money" on PBS over the weekend and they were talking about this exact phenomenon that has basically allowed the spending boom over here for the past decade. Its all because china kept buying our debt. But they are already starting to cut back and there are rumors that it may increase substantially. And if China goes away... we are screwed. Likewise, if we default... we are screwed.

Don't think for a minute China doesn't have economists that can see the writing on the wall here...
 
You are very right. We are lucky china has been so good about it so far. But I wouldn't expect them to continue eating our shit sandwich forever. I saw "The Ascent of Money" on PBS over the weekend and they were talking about this exact phenomenon that has basically allowed the spending boom over here for the past decade. Its all because china kept buying our debt. But they are already starting to cut back and there are rumors that it may increase substantially. And if China goes away... we are screwed. Likewise, if we default... we are screwed.

Don't think for a minute China doesn't have economists that can see the writing on the wall here...

I just searched for that show you mentioned. I'll watch it tonight.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-545930454338776455

Yeah you're 100% right about if China goes away. I would have to imagine what would happen to the TBill would be the EXACT equivalent of the 1929 bankrun. Every country in the world that owns our TBills would try to cash out before the other countries. And as soon as we tell the first country 'we don't have your money right now' it's game over. The USD = $0.
 
I just searched for that show you mentioned. I'll watch it tonight.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-545930454338776455

Yeah you're 100% right about if China goes away. I would have to imagine what would happen to the TBill would be the EXACT equivalent of the 1929 bankrun. Every country in the world that owns our TBills would try to cash out before the other countries. And as soon as we tell the first country 'we don't have your money right now' it's game over. The USD = $0.

Don't think so. The US$ will always (at least for many years) remain the safest place to put money in the financial system. The whole world is going through the same problems as us. However, that doesn't mean that Treasury funding costs won't go up very substantially.

Mark my words: 2009 will be the year of gov't expropriations. All these little emerging markets will have trouble raising gov't money, and those gov'ts will resort to stealing in order to stay in business. I'd be particularly wary of gold mines owned by Western companies in some really unstable places. Oil assets too.
 
depressions do not have an accepted definition. they are not defined by unemployment. ALL ECONOMIC DOWNTURNS were defined as recessions unti the 1930's when they decided to call it a depression simply because it was a bigger recession. that is why it is senseless to ask the question "are we in a depression". there is not a definition.

what i think is going to happen to the USA is either a japan type scenario or an iceland type scenario.

japan = fiscal conservatism protecting the yen resulting in 10 years of "recession" and a strong yen.
iceland = 50% reduction of the icelandic krone value in a very short time.

if obama's team is really good they will walk a fine line between iceland and japan. are they that good? we will find out. but a democratic administration will err on the side of inflation, so i see a possible 50% reduction in our purchasing power and a corresponding reduction in the USA standard of living
as a result. you will make the same take home pay but it will buy way less. this will not result in armageddon or whatever the survivalists are preaching. it will result in all of us eating out less, living in smaller homes, and basically not driving the world's best cars etc. middle class will live more like
lower middle class. less opportunities for businesses. less money for fun. less steaks and more macaroni and cheese. no trips to europe, or if you go, you will go once. less skiing in the rockies. that sort of thing.
 
depressions do not have an accepted definition. they are not defined by unemployment. ALL ECONOMIC DOWNTURNS were defined as recessions unti the 1930's when they decided to call it a depression simply because it was a bigger recession. that is why it is senseless to ask the question "are we in a depression". there is not a definition.

what i think is going to happen to the USA is either a japan type scenario or an iceland type scenario.

japan = fiscal conservatism protecting the yen resulting in 10 years of "recession" and a strong yen.
iceland = 50% reduction of the icelandic krone value in a very short time.

if obama's team is really good they will walk a fine line between iceland and japan. are they that good? we will find out. but a democratic administration will err on the side of inflation, so i see a possible 50% reduction in our purchasing power and a corresponding reduction in the USA standard of living
as a result. you will make the same take home pay but it will buy way less. this will not result in armageddon or whatever the survivalists are preaching. it will result in all of us eating out less, living in smaller homes, and basically not driving the world's best cars etc. middle class will live more like
lower middle class. less opportunities for businesses. less money for fun. less steaks and more macaroni and cheese. no trips to europe, or if you go, you will go once. less skiing in the rockies. that sort of thing.

ok, hmmm, most of our problem are really keeping up with the house mortgage, if we got same income, and I have fixed rate mortgage; then I might not be able to take my nsx out to track anymore, but at least I still living in the same house?? Is my line of thought right???
 
if obama's team is really good they will walk a fine line between iceland and japan. are they that good? we will find out. but a democratic administration will err on the side of inflation, so i see a possible 50% reduction in our purchasing power and a corresponding reduction in the USA standard of living
as a result. you will make the same take home pay but it will buy way less. this will not result in armageddon or whatever the survivalists are preaching. it will result in all of us eating out less, living in smaller homes, and basically not driving the world's best cars etc. middle class will live more like
lower middle class. less opportunities for businesses. less money for fun. less steaks and more macaroni and cheese. no trips to europe, or if you go, you will go once. less skiing in the rockies. that sort of thing.

That all sounds peaches 'n cream. "Hey, we'll all just have to accept a lower standard of living...ya, know, that sort of thing" Rigghhttt....

I wouldn't be so cavalier about how "just having to accept a lower standard of living" will affect our society, our government, and those of nations all around the world.
 
depressions do not have an accepted definition. they are not defined by unemployment. ALL ECONOMIC DOWNTURNS were defined as recessions unti the 1930's when they decided to call it a depression simply because it was a bigger recession. that is why it is senseless to ask the question "are we in a depression". there is not a definition.

Not true. The early 1890s experienced what economists today uniformly call a depression. However, it was much shorter in duration and less severe than the one in the 1930s, hence it being commonly called the Great Depression.
 
ok, hmmm, most of our problem are really keeping up with the house mortgage, if we got same income, and I have fixed rate mortgage; then I might not be able to take my nsx out to track anymore, but at least I still living in the same house?? Is my line of thought right???
if the currency is worth 50% less then your home will be worth twice as much when you sell it.
you will make out like a bandit. when inflation happens you want to be out of the dollar and in assets like houses or cars or diamonds etc.
 
Not true. The early 1890s experienced what economists today uniformly call a depression. However, it was much shorter in duration and less severe than the one in the 1930s, hence it being commonly called the Great Depression.

but what is the definition of a depression??
there is none. how do you tell a recession from a depression?
you cannot. there is no accepted definition.

from wikipedia

"Though there is no widely accepted definition for an economic depression, according to an article in The Economist, there are two rules of thumb found widely on the internet. One is a decline in real GDP exceeding 10%, and the other is a recession lasting 3 or more years.[4]"
 
I'm depressed just reading this thread. I must be in denial because I worked hard for my money, saved up to buy my home/cars/etc, and didn't buy extra homes when even the janitors could qualify for a $$million pad. People buying on margins, housewifes becoming overnight real estate agents, parents buying teens new bimmers, I could go on & on..... Whatever it is, I hope this nation learns from this over-indulgence and take responsibility for their own credit issues.

What he said X100!!!!!
 
but what is the definition of a depression??
there is none. how do you tell a recession from a depression?
you cannot. there is no accepted definition.

from wikipedia

"Though there is no widely accepted definition for an economic depression, according to an article in The Economist, there are two rules of thumb found widely on the internet. One is a decline in real GDP exceeding 10%, and the other is a recession lasting 3 or more years.[4]"

Are you serious??? Best of luck to you if these are the things that occupy your thought processes.
 
Back
Top